Pick the logos worth keeping.
Every concept the designers submitted that we liked, in one place. Go through them together and mark each one Keep or Cut. We only need to narrow the list, not pick the winner yet.
Read this first
These are all first drafts. Nothing here is final. Every one of these is a designer's opening idea, submitted exactly as-is.
For any logo you keep, we can go back to that designer and ask for changes to colors, fonts, the tagline, the icon, spacing, layout - whatever you want. So don't cut something just because the color is wrong or a word is misspelled. Judge the idea, not the finish.
Mark it Keep if you'd be happy to see a second version of it. Mark it Cut if the direction is simply wrong.